Michael Weaver,
victim

Twenty-two year-old Michael Weaver — another friend of Sappington's — was next.

It was April 10, just three days after Green's death. The voices told Sappington to go hunting again, and despite the arduous selection process he used for the second time, Sappington wound up with a victim much like Green.

Sappington spotted Weaver sitting on the steps of his house. The pair struck up a conversation with Sappington suggesting they go for a drive in Weaver's car. In a shadowy alley only three blocks from Sappington's home, he fatally stabbed Weaver.

Then Sappington went through the Terry Green routine. The voices told him to drink Weaver's blood, but he soon abandoned the task out of fear of discovery. Sappington fled, leaving the body behind.

Sappington had killed three people — Marshak, Green and Weaver. With a trio of homicides behind him, Sappington was officially now a serial killer.

Alton Freddie
Brown, victim

That murder tally did not last long, however. On his way home from the Weaver murder, Sappington spotted "Freddie," the teenager who adored Sappington. The voices liked the new target, and Sappington invited Freddie back to his house.

This time Sappington used a shotgun to kill. Finally, Sappington was free of distractions and could quaff blood. But there was one more ingredient.

Sappington crudely butchered Freddie's body, and then proceeded to feast upon raw flesh. His repast complete, he stuffed what was left of Freddie into a trash bag, leaving his leftovers on the basement floor. Then Sappington left the house, beginning what could be considered a postprandial stroll.